Is bottled water healthier or safer than tap?

Q. I know bottled water is an environmental no-no because it generates plastic and because energy is required to ship it around, but is it any healthier? I feel sort of guilty about it, but I do want to make sure I’m not drinking a bunch of chemicals. –Wallace, North Dakota 

A. There’s really no reason to think bottled water is healthier or more pure than tap. In fact, recent testing suggests that bottled water is, in the case of some brands, just tap water poured into plastic. Beverage companies aren’t required to disclose the origins of their water, or the results of any in-house testing they do for contaminants (except in California). That means that they can pretty much fill those resource-and-energy-hogging plastic bottles with any old H20, slap a picture of a mountain on it, and charge you an arm and a leg for it. The Environmental Working Group just tested ten brands of bottled water and found everything from arsenic to chlorine to fertilizer residue in them. Some brands were completely indistinguishable from municipal supplies, and contained byproducts of the disinfectants used in tap water. Funny thing, that.

The bottled water industry, not surprisingly, contends that a study of ten brands is not big enough to represent the market as a whole, but the fact is that there’s no law preventing companies from bottling ordinary tap water and selling it as something more special. Your tap water may be just as good as bottled water—and it’s literally 1,900 times cheaper on average. If you want to make sure you’re drinking the purest water possible, you’re better off investing in one of the dozens of kinds of filters on the market. And yeah, we know, sometimes you’re away from home, you’re thirsty, you forgot your trusty reusable bottle, and you find public drinking fountains more reprehensible than the thought of increasing your carbon footprint a smidgen. Sometimes it does make sense to go for that bottle of water. We won’t tell. No need for massive guilt trips. Just keep in mind that you’re only paying for convenience, not for exceptional purity of the water.

-         Sarah Schmidt 

Eco-inquiries, conundrums, snafus? Write to

See more articles from Ask Plenty


TrackBack URL for this entry:


Last year, Americans consumed 50 billion single-use bottles of water. 85% of these bottles ended up in landfills.

Single-use plastic water bottles have a devastating effect on the environment, producing 2.5 million tons of the greenhouse gas CO2 annually from manufacturing and hundreds of thousands of tons of CO2 from transportation. Also highly wasteful, the disposable bottles require more than 17 million barrels of oil annually in the U.S. alone to produce. Coupled with transportation and other costs, single-use bottles account for nearly 49 million barrels of wasted oil per year, enough to fuel three-million U.S. cars for a year.

And if the environmental issues aren't enough to convince you, think about your pockets. Bottled water costs on average $10 a gallon. Tap water costs pennies. In this time of economic instability, we could all use some tips on saving money. Tip #1: Drink tap water.

Check out our safe plastic reusable sports bottles on

Kick The Bottled Water Habit!

Post a comment

Email your questions to Tobin at Ask Plenty

Issue 25

Sign up for Plenty's Weekly Newsletter