Back to school: the bus beats the prius

Q. Should I drive my daughter the 5.5 miles to her school in my 2006 Toyota Prius, or have her take the school bus? —Meredith, CO

A. Calculations are cold, unfeeling things, and subjective to many outside factors: Is your daughter’s school on the way to your work, or would you turn around and drive right back home? Would you take the neighbors’ kid along as well? What model is the bus, and would it be full to capacity? Would it retrace its route to a garage between the morning pickups and afternoon dropoffs, or wait near the school? 

But let’s do some rough estimating. If there are 180 school days in the year, you’re driving 5.5 miles 4 times a day (twice in the morning, twice in the afternoon), for 180 days each year. That’s 3,960 miles total. According to Carbon Fund, a non-profit online carbon calculator, driving 4,000 miles in your Toyota Prius will produce about 0.65 tons of CO2. 

Now let’s talk about the bus scenario. Matthew Solomon, Mobile Source Analyst for non-profit Northeast States for Coordinated Air Use Management (NESCAUM), estimates that the average school bus (carrying 72 students and getting about 7 miles to the gallon) would emit 0.089 tons CO2, per passenger, over the course of 4000 miles. So no matter how you slice it, the bus is far and away your greenest option. Plus, putting your daughter on the bus at an early age will teach her to support public transportation—especially if you take the time to explain your logic to her.

- Tobin Hack 

Eco-inquiries, conundrums, snafus? Write to